Group homes support individuals with disabilities or mental health needs, while assisted living is designed for seniors who need help with daily tasks but want to stay independent.

The right choice depends on care needs, level of independence, and social environment. This guide breaks down the key differences, benefits, and factors to consider, helping you make the best decision.

What Is a Group Home?

A group home provides a supportive, residential setting for individuals with disabilities, mental health conditions, or other challenges that make independent living difficult. These homes typically accommodate a small number of residents, fostering a close-knit, community-oriented environment.

At All Saints Healthcare, our homes in Annandale and Falls Church, VA, offer compassionate, structured care in a home-like setting, helping residents build independence while receiving the support they need.

Key Features of a Group Home:

• Assistance with daily tasks (dressing, bathing, medication management)

• Supervision and structured routines

• Skill-building activities to promote independence

• Social and recreational opportunities

• Shared living spaces in a home-like setting

Group homes are ideal for individuals who need moderate to high support but benefit from a family-style atmosphere rather than a clinical setting.

What Is Assisted Living?

Assisted living facilities primarily serve older adults who need help with daily activities but do not require 24/7 medical care. These communities provide a balance of independence and support.

Key Features of Assisted Living:

• Private or semi-private apartments

• Assistance with activities of daily living (ADLs)

• Housekeeping and meal services

• On-site medical staff for non-intensive care

• Social and recreational activities

Assisted living is best for seniors who want a supportive, socially engaging environment with access to help when needed.

Comparison: Group Home vs. Assisted Living

Primary Residents:

• Group Home: Adults with disabilities, mental health needs

• Assisted Living: Seniors needing daily assistance

Living Environment:

• Group Home: Small home setting, shared spaces

• Assisted Living: Apartment-style or private rooms

Level of Care:

• Group Home: Personalized support, skill-building

• Assisted Living: Assistance with daily tasks, medical support

Independence Level:

• Group Home: Often requires full-time supervision

• Assisted Living: More autonomy with access to support

Social Structure:

• Group Home: Close-knit, community-based

• Assisted Living: Larger community with structured activities

Medical Support:

• Group Home: Limited medical care, focus on support & skills

• Assisted Living: On-site medical care and emergency response

Benefits of Each Option

Group Homes:

• Personalized care in a smaller, home-like environment

• Structured routines and skill-building programs

• Strong peer support and social engagement

• Dedicated supervision for safety and well-being

Assisted Living:

• Greater independence with available assistance

• Designed for aging adults needing moderate support

• Larger social network with scheduled activities

• On-site medical staff and emergency response systems

How to Decide Between a Group Home and Assisted Living

Consider the following when making a decision:

• Level of Care: Does the individual need continuous supervision or occasional help?

• Independence vs. Support: Would they benefit from a structured, skill-building setting or prefer more autonomy?

• Financial Considerations: What budget and financial aid options are available?

• Facility Environment: Visiting potential residences can provide insight into daily life and staff interactions.

Cost Comparison & Financial Assistance

• Group Homes: $3,000 – $7,000 per month (varies by location and services)

• Assisted Living: $4,000 – $8,000 per month (based on facility and care level)

• Financial Aid: Medicaid, state-funded programs, long-term care insurance, and nonprofit assistance may help offset costs.

Common Misconceptions

• Myth: Group homes only serve individuals with severe disabilities.
  Reality: They accommodate a range of needs, from mild to significant support requirements.

• Myth: Assisted living is just an expensive nursing home.
  Reality: Assisted living provides moderate support, unlike nursing homes, which offer intensive medical care.

• Myth: Group homes and assisted living provide the same medical care.
  Reality: Assisted living facilities typically have on-site medical staff, while group homes focus on supportive care.

Making the Right Choice

Choosing the right living arrangement depends on individual needs, lifestyle preferences, and required support. Group homes provide a close-knit, supportive environment for those with disabilities or mental health needs, while assisted living offers more independence with accessible care for aging adults.

For the best care option, contact All Saints Healthcare to learn more about our residential group homes in Annandale and Falls Church, VA.